We all know that moment. You type your ZIP code into a “compare car insurance” site, fill in your name and phone number, hit the big green button, and before you even put your phone down it starts ringing. Then a text. Then another call from a number in a state you’ve never been to. If that happened to you after visiting Otto, you’re not alone, and this review explains why.
Otto Insurance is a real company, OTTO Quotes, LLC in Miami Beach, Florida, but it does not sell insurance. It is a quote-matching site that passes your details to insurers and agents, who then call, text and email you. On Trustpilot it scores 1.5 out of 5, and 76% of reviews are one star, mostly about calls.
What is Otto Insurance?
Otto Insurance is a lead generation website run by OTTO Quotes, LLC, based at 1111 Lincoln Road in Miami Beach, Florida. It does not write policies or pay claims. You fill in a form about your car or home, and Otto matches you with insurance companies and agents who may give you a quote. Those partners pay for your contact details.
Otto calls itself “an unbiased insurance marketplace tool.” Its privacy policy is more direct: users are “matched to insurance carriers and agents who may provide you a quote.” So when you use Otto, you’re not buying from Otto. You’re handing your info to whoever Otto sends it to.
Here are the basic facts, checked against Otto’s own pages and the Florida business record:
| Detail | What we found |
|---|---|
| Legal name | OTTO Quotes, LLC (was “OTTO Quote, LLC” until Aug 2022) |
| Registered in Florida | 31 January 2022, as an out-of-state (foreign) LLC, status active |
| Managers on the filing | Joshua Keller and Nick Matzorkis |
| Address | 1111 Lincoln Road, Suite 657, Miami Beach, FL 33139 |
| What it covers | Auto, home and pet quotes (its October 2025 press release adds life) |
| Is it an insurer? | No |
| License number shown on site | None |
| Cost to you | Free. Partners pay Otto |
| Phone numbers listed | 1-800-HEY-OTTO (1-800-439-6886), (855) 538-2252 and 1-888-904-1907 |
A few things on Otto’s own site don’t line up. The homepage says Otto has helped “over 40 million” people. The reviews page says “11 Million Strong.” Three different pages list three different phone numbers. None of that makes it a scam, but it tells you the site is built for sales, not for clear answers.
Is Otto Insurance legit or a scam?
Otto is a legitimate, registered business, so it is not a scam in the legal sense. It also isn’t an insurance company. Your quote request goes to insurers and agents you don’t pick, and they can contact you by automated calls and texts. Most complaints say Otto feels like a scam because of the calls, not because money went missing.
The difference matters. A scam takes your money for a policy that doesn’t exist. Otto never takes payment and never sells you a policy. If you buy insurance after using Otto, you buy it from a real carrier like Progressive or Allstate, and that carrier issues your policy.
Where people get burned is privacy. Your name, phone, email, address, car and driving history go to companies you didn’t choose. One August 2026 Trustpilot reviewer said his info ended up with a caller pretending to be Allstate. That’s the real risk here: once your number is out, you can’t control who buys it next.
Want to check any insurance seller’s license? Use the NAIC State Based Systems license lookup or your state insurance department’s site. Otto doesn’t list a license number, so ask any agent who calls you for theirs.
How does Otto Insurance work?
You answer a short form about your vehicle, your driving record and your current insurer. Otto then shows you one or more insurer links or connects you with an agent, and shares your details with partners in its network. Those partners can call, text and email you. You never get a list of everyone who received your information.
Here’s what happens step by step:
- You pick auto, home or pet on ottoinsurance.com.
- You enter your ZIP code, car, date of birth, driving history and current insurer.
- The last page asks for your name, phone and email. Submitting this page is where you give consent to be contacted.
- Otto shows a result. Testers often got one insurer link or zero quotes. Compare.com got no quotes at all in its test. RateRetriever ran three tests in 2024 and got one match each time (USAA, Experian and Progressive).
- Your info goes out to Otto’s partners. Otto says it works with “hundreds of insurance carriers” but doesn’t publish the list.
- Calls and texts start, often within minutes. Jerry’s writer used a Google Voice number and got five spam calls within an hour.
So you don’t actually see side-by-side prices on Otto, the way the word “compare” suggests. You see a link, and the rest of the “comparing” happens over the phone.
What do real Otto Insurance reviews say?
Real reviews are mostly negative. On Trustpilot, OTTO Quotes scores 1.5 out of 5 from about 70 reviews, with 76% one-star and 17% five-star. Nearly every complaint is about calls, texts and data sharing after using the site. The newest five-star review is from February 2025.
Here’s the Trustpilot breakdown as of 17 November 2026:
| Stars | Share of reviews |
|---|---|
| 5 stars | 17% |
| 4 stars | 0% |
| 3 stars | 4% |
| 2 stars | 3% |
| 1 star | 76% |
Otto claimed its Trustpilot profile in December 2023 and replies to every negative review, but usually more than a month later, and the replies are copy-paste messages telling you to email info@ottoinsurance.com.
What the one-star reviews say, in their words or close to it:
- Calls right away. A September 2026 reviewer said calls and texts started within minutes of asking for a quote. Another that same month said she got 8 to 10 calls in five minutes, and it went on for days.
- No quote at all. A June 2026 reviewer said the site errored out and then the calls from other insurers began anyway.
- Wrong company. A March 2026 reviewer got a link to Allstate, a phone rep named a different carrier, and a Farmers agent called him right after.
- “Not an insurance company.” Several people didn’t realize Otto doesn’t sell policies until after they submitted.
And the good ones? There are only a handful. A March 2024 reviewer said they got calls but found a cheaper plan. A February 2026 three-star reviewer said his rate dropped from about $100 to $73 a month, but he got lots of calls after. So some people do save money. They just pay for it with their phone.
You’ll also see glowing testimonials on Otto’s own reviews page, like “saved me $115 a month.” Those are written and posted by Otto, with no rating, no date and no way to check them. Otto’s own pros and cons list says one “con” is that it “could save you too much money.” Take that page as an ad.
One more thing: most of the “Otto review” articles ranking on Google come from competing brokers, lead sites and comparison sites. Compare.com, for example, is owned by Insurify, which also reviews Otto. Their tests are still useful, but keep that in mind.
For the Better Business Bureau grade, check bbb.org yourself. Ranking pages quote anything from an A to “not rated,” so we didn’t want to guess.
Why do you get so many calls after using Otto?
Because you agreed to them. Otto’s privacy policy says its partners may contact you “by telephone (including through automated calling or on a recorded line), email, or regular mail,” even if your number is on the National Do Not Call Registry. Submitting the quote form counts as your written consent to those calls.
Most people never read the privacy policy, so here’s what Otto’s (last updated 27 July 2024) actually says:
- Partners may call with automated dialers, “even if you have opted into the National Do Not Call List.”
- To stop a partner from contacting you, you have to “make a request to that Service Provider.” Otto can’t do it for you.
- Partners “may maintain the information you provided whether or not you elect to use their services.” So even if you never buy, they keep your data.
- Otto keeps the records of your consent for 6 years.
- The form uses a tracking tool (LogRocket) that can record your keystrokes as you type, plus Meta and Google tracking pixels.
- In the California privacy section, Otto says it has “shared personal information” in the last 12 months, and you opt out of the sale of your data by emailing privacyrights@ottoinsurance.com.
Why is this legal? The Do Not Call Registry stops sales calls from companies you haven’t given permission to. When you submit a form like Otto’s, you give written permission, so the registry no longer protects you from those callers.
In 2023 the FCC tried to close this gap with a “one-to-one consent” rule. It would have made each form cover only one seller, named on the page. Insurance and lead generation groups sued, and in January 2025 the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals struck the rule down in Insurance Marketing Coalition v. FCC, days before it was set to start. The FCC formally removed it by an order dated 14 July 2025. That means one form on one site can still give consent to many companies at once.
You’re far from the only one fed up. The FTC logged 2.62 million Do Not Call complaints in fiscal year 2025, and about 61% were about robocalls. There are 259 million phone numbers on the registry.
Can Otto really save you $500 a year?
Maybe, but Otto doesn’t show the proof. Its homepage says “survey data indicates it is possible to save $500+ per year,” without sharing the survey. $500 a year works out to about $42 a month, which is a realistic saving for many drivers who shop around, whether or not they use Otto.
Here’s the simple math. Say you pay $180 a month for full coverage today:
- $180 x 12 = $2,160 a year.
- Save $500 and you pay $1,660 a year, or about $138 a month.
- That’s a 23% drop.
Shopping around can get you there. The three-star Trustpilot reviewer went from about $100 to $73 a month, which is $324 a year. But that saving comes from the insurer that quoted you, not from Otto. You can get the same quote by going to that insurer directly, without your number going to a list of partners.
How do you stop Otto Insurance calls and texts?
Email Otto at requesttodelete@ottoinsurance.com with your phone number and email, then tell every company that calls to put you on its internal Do Not Call list. Otto’s opt-out only stops Otto. Each partner that bought your details has to be told separately, because Otto’s privacy policy says so.
Do this in order:
- Email Otto. Send your phone number and email to requesttodelete@ottoinsurance.com. Otto says it replies within 24 to 48 hours. Copy privacyrights@ottoinsurance.com and ask them to stop selling or sharing your data.
- Reply STOP to every text. That’s the fastest opt-out for texts.
- On every call, say: “Put me on your internal Do Not Call list and revoke my consent.” Write down the company name, the date and the number. Under FCC rules that took effect in April 2025, a company has to honor your opt-out within 10 business days, and you can say it any reasonable way.
- Ask the caller where they got your number. Legit agents will tell you. If they name Otto, you know the source. If they won’t say, hang up.
- Check your number on the Do Not Call Registry at donotcall.gov. It costs nothing. It won’t block companies you gave consent to, but it helps with everyone else.
- Report callers who keep calling after you told them to stop, at reportfraud.ftc.gov or donotcall.gov. Keep your notes from step 3, they’re your proof.
- Turn on your carrier’s spam filter. T-Mobile Scam Shield, Verizon Call Filter and AT&T ActiveArmor all have free versions.
Expect the calls to slow down over 1 to 2 weeks, not stop overnight. Some reviewers say new numbers keep popping up for a while, because the data may have been passed on again.
Should you use Otto to compare car insurance?
Only if you don’t mind sales calls and want someone else to find an insurer for you. If you want to see prices side by side, Otto isn’t built for that. Testers often got one link or no quotes. Most drivers will do better getting quotes straight from three insurers or from an independent agent.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Free to use | Not an insurer, can’t sell you a policy |
| Short form, takes a few minutes | Often shows one link or no quotes |
| Covers auto, home and pet | Your data goes to partners you don’t pick |
| Some users found cheaper rates | Calls and texts within minutes, even on the Do Not Call Registry |
| Real registered company | 1.5/5 on Trustpilot, 76% one-star |
| No license number or partner list on the site |
Otto can work for you if: – You’re happy to talk to agents on the phone. – You use a spare number (Google Voice is free) and a spare email. – You don’t have time to visit three insurer sites yourself.
Skip it if: – You hate phone calls. – You want to see actual prices before talking to anyone. – You care about who holds your personal data.
What are better ways to compare car insurance quotes?
Go directly to two or three insurers’ websites and enter the same coverage on each. It takes 20 to 30 minutes and nobody buys your number. You can also call one independent insurance agent, who can quote several companies at once. Use a spare phone number if you try any lead site.
Here’s a simple way to do it:
- Pull up your current policy and write down your limits, like 100/300/100 liability and a $500 deductible.
- Get quotes from three insurers directly using those exact limits. Start with our list of cheap car insurance companies to pick which three.
- If you barely drive, look at pay-per-mile or app-based insurers. Our Lemonade car insurance review shows how that math works.
- Call one independent agent in your town. One call, several quotes, and you know exactly who has your number.
- Compare total cost for 6 or 12 months, along with the monthly number, and check whether each quote includes the same discounts.
If you still want to try Otto or any similar site, use a Google Voice number and an email you don’t care about. That way, when the calls start, you can just ignore them.
FAQ
Is Otto Insurance a real insurance company? No. Otto is a quote-matching website run by OTTO Quotes, LLC in Miami Beach, Florida. It passes your information to insurers and agents. It doesn’t issue policies or pay claims.
Is Otto Insurance a scam? It’s not a scam in the sense of taking your money. It’s a registered company and never charges you. Most complaints are about calls, texts and data sharing after you fill in the form.
Who owns Otto Insurance? OTTO Quotes, LLC owns it. The Florida business filing lists Joshua Keller and Nick Matzorkis as managers. The company was registered in Florida on 31 January 2022.
Why am I getting calls after using Otto? Submitting Otto’s form gives its partners permission to call you, including with automated calls, even if your number is on the Do Not Call Registry. That’s in Otto’s privacy policy.
How do I stop Otto Insurance from calling me? Email requesttodelete@ottoinsurance.com with your phone number and email. Then tell each company that calls to put you on its internal Do Not Call list. Otto’s opt-out doesn’t cover its partners.
What is Otto Insurance’s phone number? Otto lists three: 1-800-HEY-OTTO (1-800-439-6886), (855) 538-2252 and 1-888-904-1907. Its email is info@ottoinsurance.com.
What is Otto Insurance’s Trustpilot rating? 1.5 out of 5 from about 70 reviews as of November 2026. 76% of reviews are one star and 17% are five star.
Does Otto Insurance sell my data? Otto’s privacy policy says it has shared personal information in the last 12 months and lets you opt out of the “sale” of your data by emailing privacyrights@ottoinsurance.com. Its partners can keep your data even if you don’t buy from them.
Is Otto Insurance free? Yes. You pay nothing. Insurers and agents pay Otto for your contact details.
Otto Insurance is a real, registered company, but it’s a lead site, not an insurer. You give it your details, and it gives them to insurers and agents who will call you, a lot. Some people do find a cheaper rate this way. Most of the 70-odd Trustpilot reviewers mainly found a phone that wouldn’t stop ringing.
If you want to save money on car insurance without the calls, get three quotes directly and compare the same coverage. Start with our cheap car insurance companies list.










