If your dog has ever swallowed a sock, or your cat suddenly stopped eating for two days, you know the feeling. You walk into the emergency vet, they hand you an estimate, and the number has a comma in it. That’s usually the moment people start googling pet insurance, and Pumpkin is one of the names that shows up first because their ads are everywhere.
Pumpkin is a good pick if you want broad accident and illness cover with no upper age limit and a short 14-day wait for everything, knees and hips included. It is not the cheapest. A 2-year-old medium mixed breed dog in Katy, Texas costs about $32 a month and an 8-year-old French bulldog about $158 (NerdWallet sample rates).
This review shows you what Pumpkin really costs, what it covers and doesn’t, how much a claim actually pays you after the deductible, and who should look somewhere else.
Pumpkin pet insurance at a glance
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Plan type | Accident and illness only. No accident-only plan |
| Reimbursement | 80% or 90% |
| Annual deductible | $100, $250, $500 or $1,000 |
| Annual limit, dogs | $5,000, $10,000, $20,000 or unlimited |
| Annual limit, cats | $5,000, $7,000, $15,000 or unlimited |
| Waiting period | 14 days for accidents and illnesses in most states, including knee injuries and hip dysplasia |
| Age limits | 8 weeks and up. No upper age limit |
| Breed limits | None |
| Multi-pet discount | 10% for each additional pet |
| Vets | Any licensed vet, specialist or emergency hospital in the US or Canada |
| Claim deadline | 270 days |
| Money-back period | 30 days in most states, if no claim was paid or approved |
| Underwriters | Independence American Insurance Company or United States Fire Insurance Company |
| Trustpilot | 4.8 out of 5 from 4,008 reviews (November 2026) |
All plan details are from Pumpkin’s own pages, read November 17, 2026.
Is Pumpkin pet insurance good?
Yes, for most dog and cat owners who want one solid plan without fine print about breeds or age. Pumpkin covers exam fees, dental illness, behavioral problems, hereditary conditions and alternative therapies with no add-on fees, and makes you wait only 14 days for knee and hip problems, where many insurers make you wait 6 to 12 months.
The downside is price. Pumpkin sits in the middle to upper part of the market. Insurify’s national averages put Pumpkin at $78 a month for dogs and $32 for cats, against $38 and $21 for Lemonade and $57 and $28 for Pets Best (May 2026). Forbes Advisor gave Pumpkin 21 out of 50 on its price-value index, and NerdWallet gave it 5 out of 5 stars overall. So the people reviewing it agree on the coverage and disagree on whether it’s worth the money.
You also don’t get an app, an accident-only plan, or direct payment to every vet. More on those below.
How much does Pumpkin pet insurance cost?
Pumpkin doesn’t publish prices, so you need a quote. In NerdWallet’s Katy, Texas sample rates ($250 deductible, $5,000 limit, 80%), dogs cost $32 to $64 a month at age 2 and $80 to $158 at age 8. Cats cost $15 to $28 at age 2 and $28 to $52 at age 8.
Here’s what that looks like by breed. These are monthly prices from NerdWallet, updated May 2026.
| Pet | Age 2 | Age 8 |
|---|---|---|
| Medium mixed breed dog | $32 | $80 |
| German shepherd | $40 | $98 |
| Labrador retriever | $45 | $112 |
| Poodle | $45 | $112 |
| Golden retriever | $46 | $116 |
| French bulldog | $64 | $158 |
| Domestic shorthair cat | $15 | $28 |
| Devon rex cat | $16 | $30 |
| Ragdoll cat | $17 | $32 |
| Persian cat | $22 | $41 |
| Maine coon cat | $23 | $43 |
| Exotic longhair cat | $28 | $52 |
Look at the age jump. The same French bulldog costs about 2.5 times more at 8 than at 2. If you’re buying for a puppy, budget for the price to climb every year.
What moves your Pumpkin price the most
Your deductible and annual limit change the price more than anything else you control. Insurify priced the same 2-year-old medium dog in Hartford, Connecticut at 90% reimbursement:
| Annual limit | $1,000 deductible | $500 deductible | $250 deductible | $100 deductible |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | $43.59 | $64.59 | $85.83 | $103.52 |
| $20,000 | $57.16 | $84.70 | $112.55 | $135.73 |
| Unlimited | $62.36 | $92.41 | $122.79 | $148.09 |
Same dog, same city. The cheapest setup costs $43.59 a month and the most generous one costs $148.09, about 3.4 times more. For a 2-year-old shorthair cat, Insurify’s grid runs $20.56 a month ($7,000 limit, $1,000 deductible) up to $82.00 (unlimited, $100 deductible).
That’s why you see the same Labrador priced at $45 on one review site and $141 on another. They’re quoting different deductibles, limits, ages and zip codes.
How Pumpkin compares to the national average
The average US pet owner paid $836 a year for a dog’s accident and illness policy in 2025, up 11.5% from 2024, and $435 a year for a cat, up 12.6%, according to NAPHIA’s 2026 State of the Industry report. That works out to about $70 a month for dogs and $36 for cats. Pumpkin’s young-pet prices come in under that, and its older-pet prices come in over it.
What does Pumpkin cover?
Pumpkin’s accident and illness plan covers vet exams for sick or hurt pets, diagnostics, surgery, hospital stays, cancer treatment, dental illness, behavioral problems, hereditary and congenital conditions like hip dysplasia, prescription meds, prescription food for covered conditions, alternative therapies and physical therapy. There is no extra charge for any of these.
Pumpkin’s own list of what’s included without add-on fees:
- Accidents, such as broken bones, swallowed objects, bite wounds and poisoning
- Illnesses, such as ear infections, UTIs, diabetes and cancer
- Exam fees for accident and illness visits, in-office and virtual
- Dental illness, including gum disease and tooth extractions after an injury or disease
- Behavioral problems, such as anxiety or compulsive licking (vet treatment, not training)
- Hereditary and congenital conditions, including hip dysplasia
- Prescription food and supplements when they treat a covered condition
- Alternative therapies like acupuncture, and physical therapy for covered conditions
- Microchip implantation and euthanasia (listed as covered by Insurify and Pumpkin’s Nationwide comparison page)
Exam fees matter because you pay one at nearly every sick visit, and some insurers only cover them if you buy an extra rider.
What doesn’t Pumpkin cover?
Pumpkin doesn’t cover pre-existing conditions that it considers incurable, routine care like vaccines and checkups, cosmetic procedures, breeding costs, herbal supplements and CBD, house-call fees, or dental cleanings that aren’t treating a diagnosed illness. Routine care is only paid through a separate add-on or membership.
Here’s the exclusions list in plain terms, based on Pumpkin’s pages and Insurify’s review:
- Pre-existing conditions (see the next section for the curable exception)
- Wellness and routine care: vaccines, annual exams, flea and tick meds, spay or neuter
- Cleanings that aren’t treating gum disease or another diagnosed problem
- Cosmetic procedures, such as tail docking or ear cropping
- Breeding, pregnancy and whelping
- Herbal treatments and supplements, including CBD
- House-call and travel fees
- Injuries from neglect or mistreatment
How does Pumpkin handle pre-existing conditions?
Pumpkin won’t cover a condition that showed signs before your policy started or during the 14-day wait. But if it was curable, was cured, and your pet then goes 180 days with no symptoms or treatment, Pumpkin covers it if it comes back. Knee and hind-leg ligament problems are the exception.
Here’s how that plays out:
- Your cat had a UTI three months before you signed up. It cleared up. If she stays symptom and treatment free for 180 days, a later UTI is covered.
- Your dog had a paw fracture last year that healed. Same rule. After 180 days clear, a new paw injury is covered.
- Your dog was limping on a back leg during the waiting period and the vet found a partial ligament tear. Pumpkin excludes future knee and hind-leg ligament claims. That includes the other knee, because Pumpkin’s rule covers knee and hind-leg ligament conditions as a group.
- Your dog has diabetes or allergies before you enroll. These don’t get “cured”, so they stay excluded for the life of the policy.
The lesson: buy insurance while your pet is young and healthy, before anything shows up in the vet record.
How long is Pumpkin’s waiting period?
Pumpkin’s waiting period is 14 days for accidents and illnesses in most states, and that same 14 days applies to cruciate ligament injuries and hip dysplasia. Many competitors make you wait 6 months or a full year for knee problems, so this is one of Pumpkin’s real advantages.
Pumpkin’s own wording is “14-day waiting period or less”, because a few states set shorter waits by law. Your policy documents list the exact wait for your state.
The 14-day accident wait does cut both ways. Some insurers start accident cover after only a few days. If your dog gets hit by a car on day 10 with Pumpkin, you’re paying that bill yourself. Yahoo Finance’s review counted this as a con for exactly that reason.
How much will Pumpkin actually pay on a claim?
Pumpkin subtracts your annual deductible from the covered bill first, then pays 80% or 90% of what’s left. On a $4,000 surgery with a $250 deductible, the 90% plan pays $3,375 and you pay $625. The 80% plan pays $3,000 and you pay $1,000.
Let’s work through it with a $4,000 bill for a swallowed toy that needs surgery. This is an example, not a quoted price.
| Step | 90% plan | 80% plan |
|---|---|---|
| Covered vet bill | $4,000 | $4,000 |
| Minus $250 annual deductible | $3,750 | $3,750 |
| Pumpkin pays (90% or 80%) | $3,375 | $3,000 |
| You pay | $625 | $1,000 |
The deductible is annual, so once you’ve met it, the next claim that year gets the full 80% or 90%. A second $1,000 bill in the same year would get $900 back on the 90% plan.
When does Pumpkin pay back more than you paid in?
Take Insurify’s Hartford dog: $64.59 a month at a $10,000 limit, $500 deductible and 90%. That’s $775 a year in premiums.
- To get $775 back, Pumpkin has to pay 90% of what’s left after the $500 deductible.
- $775 ÷ 0.9 = $861 above the deductible.
- $861 + $500 = about $1,361 in covered vet bills in one year.
So in a year with no vet bills, you’re out $775. In a year with one emergency surgery, you’re well ahead. If you can’t comfortably pay a $3,000 or $4,000 vet bill out of savings, that trade usually makes sense. If you can, putting the money into an emergency fund is a fair alternative.
How do you file a Pumpkin claim and how fast does it pay?
You upload your itemized vet invoice through Pumpkin’s online account or email it to claims@pumpkin.care within 270 days of treatment. Pumpkin pays you back by direct deposit or check. For big eligible bills, PumpkinNow can pay you before you check out at the vet.
The standard steps:
- Pay your vet as usual and ask for an itemized invoice.
- Log in to your Pumpkin account and submit the claim with the invoice. You can also email it.
- Pumpkin may ask your vet for medical records.
- Pumpkin pays you by direct deposit or paper check.
Review sites report fast payouts. MoneyGeek says reimbursements usually arrive in 24 to 48 hours, and Rover says 2 to 4 days. Pumpkin itself doesn’t publish an average.
PumpkinNow is Pumpkin’s answer to “I can’t front $5,000”. You send an estimate or invoice for eligible care and Pumpkin pays up to 90% before you pay the clinic. Pumpkin says this can happen “in minutes”. NerdWallet reports it works for bills of $500 or more and needs a bank that accepts real-time payments. It isn’t direct payment to the vet, and it doesn’t run on Sundays according to MoneyGeek.
If you need the insurer to pay the vet directly every time, look at Trupanion instead. We covered how it works in our best pet insurance in Canada roundup.
What are Preventive Essentials and the Pumpkin Wellness Club?
Both pay for routine care that the insurance plan excludes, and neither is insurance. Preventive Essentials is an add-on you can only buy with a Pumpkin policy, not sold in seven states. The Pumpkin Wellness Club is a separate membership starting at $20.95 a month for dogs and $15.95 for cats.
Preventive Essentials covers a yearly wellness exam, a set number of vaccines (two for adult dogs, four for puppies, one for cats) and a parasite screening, according to Insurify. It isn’t available in California, Maine, Missouri, Montana, Rhode Island, Vermont or Washington. Pumpkin doesn’t publish the price; you see it in your quote.
Pumpkin Wellness Club has three tiers: Essential, Premium and Elite. It works with any licensed vet in the US or Canada, you don’t need a Pumpkin insurance policy, and paying yearly gets you one month free. Yearly limits on the Essential tier, from Pumpkin’s page:
| Essential tier benefit | Dogs (from $20.95/mo) | Cats (from $15.95/mo) |
|---|---|---|
| Wellness exam | $115 | $115 |
| Vaccinations | $100 | $100 |
| Fecal test | $50 | $40 |
| Routine bloodwork | $50 | Not included |
Premium adds flea, tick and heartworm prevention plus $150 toward spay, neuter or a dental cleaning. Elite adds a grooming allowance of $180 for dogs and $100 for cats. All tiers include a 24/7 pet health phone line.
One thing to watch: Wellness Club is a 12-month membership. If you cancel early after using benefits, Pumpkin can charge you the fees you still owe for the year.
Does it pay off? For an adult dog on the Essential tier, the benefits listed above add up to $315 a year. At $20.95 a month you pay $251 a year, so you come out about $64 ahead, but only if you actually use the exam, vaccines, fecal test and bloodwork every year.
What do Pumpkin customers say?
Customers rate Pumpkin highly on Trustpilot, 4.8 out of 5 from 4,008 reviews as of November 2026. The complaints that do come up are mostly about claims denied for pre-existing conditions and premiums going up after a pet gets a serious diagnosis.
Ratings from other sites are lower. Insurify’s May 2026 review lists Google at 4.4 stars from 1,342 reviews, Yelp at 2.6 from 101 reviews, and the Better Business Bureau at a C+ rating with 31 complaints in three years. Pumpkin is not BBB accredited.
The pattern makes sense. People who file a claim and get paid in a day leave five stars. People whose claim was denied because of a vet note from before they enrolled leave one star. Read your pet’s vet records before you buy so you know what Pumpkin is likely to call pre-existing.
Who underwrites Pumpkin pet insurance?
Pumpkin is an insurance agency, not an insurer. Its policies are underwritten by Independence American Insurance Company (NAIC #26581, Scottsdale, Arizona) or United States Fire Insurance Company (NAIC #21113, New Jersey), depending on your policy form. Pumpkin Insurance Services Inc. sells and administers them.
United States Fire Insurance Company is part of Crum & Forster. Some review sites name only one underwriter, but Pumpkin’s own footer lists both. Check the declarations page of your policy to see which one backs yours.
Who should pick Pumpkin, and who should look elsewhere?
Pick Pumpkin if your pet is a large breed prone to knee or hip problems, if your pet is older, or if you want exam fees and behavioral care included. Look elsewhere if you want the lowest price, an accident-only plan, a mobile app, or a vet paid directly at checkout every time.
| Pumpkin is a good fit if | Look elsewhere if |
|---|---|
| You have a Lab, golden, Rottweiler or other breed with knee and hip risks (14-day wait) | You only want cheap accident-only cover |
| Your pet is 10 or older (no upper age limit) | You want the insurer to pay your vet directly on every bill |
| You have two or more pets (10% off each extra pet) | You want to manage claims in a phone app |
| You want exam fees, dental illness and behavioral care included | You have a young mixed breed and want the lowest monthly price |
| You want an unlimited annual limit option | Your pet already has a knee or ligament problem on record |
How to get the best price on Pumpkin
- Get a quote at two or three deductibles. On Insurify’s Hartford dog, going from a $250 to a $500 deductible saved $21.24 a month at the $10,000 limit, about $255 a year.
- Pick a limit you’d really use. $10,000 a year covers most single surgeries. Unlimited costs $27.82 more a month than $10,000 on the same dog with a $500 deductible, about $334 a year.
- Compare 80% and 90%. The 80% plan costs less each month, but on a $4,000 bill it leaves you $375 more to pay. Decide which hurts more.
- Enroll young. Prices start lower and nothing is pre-existing yet.
- Add every pet at once. Each additional pet gets 10% off.
- Use the 30-day window. If the policy wording surprises you, you can cancel for a full refund in most states as long as you haven’t had a claim paid or approved.
- Skip the wellness add-on unless you’ll use it. Add up what you spend on exams and vaccines now and compare it to the yearly cost.
Frequently asked questions
Is Pumpkin pet insurance worth it?
It’s worth it if a surprise $3,000 to $5,000 vet bill would hurt your finances. Based on Insurify’s Hartford dog quote ($775 a year), you’d need about $1,361 in covered bills in one year to come out ahead.
How much is Pumpkin pet insurance per month?
It depends on your pet, age, zip code and plan. NerdWallet’s Katy, Texas rates run $32 to $64 a month for 2-year-old dogs and $15 to $28 for 2-year-old cats, with a $250 deductible, $5,000 limit and 80% reimbursement.
Does Pumpkin pet insurance have a waiting period?
Yes. It’s 14 days for accidents and illnesses in most states, including cruciate ligament injuries and hip dysplasia. A few states set shorter waits.
Does Pumpkin cover pre-existing conditions?
Not incurable ones. Curable conditions are covered if your pet has gone 180 days with no symptoms or treatment, except knee and hind-leg ligament conditions, which stay excluded.
Does Pumpkin pay the vet directly?
Not as a standard feature. You pay the vet and Pumpkin reimburses you. PumpkinNow can send you the money before checkout for eligible bills, which NerdWallet says must be $500 or more.
Does Pumpkin have an age limit?
No upper age limit. Pets can enroll from 8 weeks old, and Pumpkin says it won’t reduce coverage as your pet ages. Premiums do rise with age.
Is Pumpkin pet insurance available in every state?
The insurance plan is sold nationwide, and you can use any licensed vet in the US or Canada. The Preventive Essentials add-on isn’t sold in CA, ME, MO, MT, RI, VT or WA.
Can I cancel Pumpkin pet insurance?
Yes, any time. If you cancel within 30 days and haven’t had a claim paid or approved, you get a full refund in most states. After that, refunds are prorated. Wellness Club memberships run 12 months and can carry fees if you cancel early.
Who owns Pumpkin pet insurance?
Pumpkin Insurance Services Inc., based in New York, sells and administers the plans. The policies are underwritten by Independence American Insurance Company or United States Fire Insurance Company.
Does Pumpkin cover dental?
It covers dental illness and injury, such as gum disease, broken teeth and extractions. It doesn’t cover routine cleanings unless they treat a diagnosed problem. Wellness Club Premium and Elite include $150 toward spay, neuter or a cleaning.
Pumpkin gives you wide coverage with very few traps: no breed rules, no age cap, 14 days for knees and hips, and exam fees included. You pay a bit more for that than you would with the cheapest names. Get a quote with a $500 deductible and a $10,000 limit first, then move the numbers around and see what your monthly price does.










